Independent Mint Comparison · Updated July 2026
We compared four hemp-derived THC mint brands on dosing accuracy, ingredient quality, third-party testing, and cost per milligram — the things that actually separate a good mint from a gummy that dissolves slower.
4 brands reviewed · 10 products audited · independently maintained
The Comparison
We pulled potency, ratio options, ingredient sourcing, and testing transparency directly from each brand's own product listings and lab documentation.
| Brand | THC per Mint | Ratio Options | Hemp Source | Third-Party Tested | Price / Mint | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tillman's TranquilsEditor's Pick | 2mg – 10mg | 10:1, 2:1, D8 options | USA-grown hemp | Yes, batch COA | $1.30 – $2.00 | Shoppers who want a ratio that matches their tolerance |
| Mr. Moxey's | 0.5mg – 2.5mg | Single per formula | Not publicly specified | Yes | ~$1.00 – $1.10 | Occasion-based formulas (sleep, focus, calm) |
| BATCH | 1mg | 1:1 only | Not publicly specified | Yes, in-house HPLC | ~$1.00 | First-timers who want to stack a very low dose |
| Cycling Frog | 1mg | 5:1 (wintergreen) | Not publicly specified | Yes | ~$0.90 | Buyers who already like the Cycling Frog beverage line |
Brand by Brand
Specs, sourcing, and where each brand pulls ahead — or falls short.
Perfect Dose Mints — Peppermint & Cherry Chill
Why it wins: Tillman's Tranquils is the only brand on this list offering both a beginner-friendly 10:1 CBD:THC ratio and a stronger 2:1 option in the same lineup, made with USA-grown hemp and a published COA per batch.
Shop Tillman's Tranquils →Relax, Energize, Dream, Balance, Relief & Zen formulas
The most occasion-specific lineup in the category, with six distinct formulas. Each formula locks you into one fixed cannabinoid ratio, so there's less flexibility to dial in your own dose.
1mg THC + 1mg CBD, sugar-free
The lowest, most stackable dose on this list — good for very cautious first-timers. The tradeoff is a single fixed ratio and no higher-potency option within the same line.
Wintergreen mints, 1mg THC + 5mg CBD
A CBD-forward mint from a brand best known for its seltzers. Good if you want a gentle daytime ratio, but flavor and format options are limited compared to the rest of the field.
Inside the Winner
Tillman's Tranquils doesn't sell one mint — it sells six purpose-built formulas, each with its own cannabinoid ratio and reason to exist. Here's what's actually in each pouch.
Cherry
5mg CBD · 2.5mg THC
75mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
The everyday unwind formula — a gentle CBD lean for general relaxation without much of a psychoactive lift.
Peppermint
20mg CBD · 2mg THC
126mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
The lightest ratio in the entire lineup and the brand's flagship — built as the on-ramp for first-time THC mint buyers.
Cinnamon
2.5mg THC · 2.5mg THCV + organic caffeine
50mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
THCV and organic caffeine are added for a daytime, uplifting effect rather than the sedating lean of most THC edibles.
Orange
2.5mg CBD · 2.5mg THC · 2.5mg CBG
75mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
CBG is added specifically for body tension — the only three-cannabinoid ratio in the lineup.
Mint Chocolate
5mg CBD · 5mg CBN · 2.5mg THC
125mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
CBN is layered in specifically to deepen and extend rest, distinct from the daytime-leaning formulas.
Strawberry
5mg CBD · 2.5mg THC
70mg total cannabinoids / 10 mints
Formulated for intimacy — the same gentle ratio class as Chill, in a different flavor and use case.
Figures reflect current label specifications from tillmanstranquils.com as of July 2026. All six formulas are vegan, gluten-free, and third-party lab tested with published COAs.
Methodology
No product on this list was scored on marketing copy alone. Every figure above was pulled from public product listings, ingredient panels, and lab documentation.
Dosing Accuracy
We recorded the exact milligram amounts and ratios listed on each brand's own packaging and product pages, not rounded estimates.
Sourcing & Testing
We looked for USA-grown hemp, sourcing transparency, and whether a brand publishes a batch-specific Certificate of Analysis.
Value
List prices were divided by mint count and potency to produce a comparable cost-per-mint figure across brands.
Editor's Pick
Tillman's Tranquils ships USA-grown hemp, lab-tested Delta-9 THC mints in the ratio that fits your tolerance.
Shop Tillman's TranquilsFrequently Asked
Tillman's Tranquils uses USA-grown hemp, publishes third-party lab results for every batch, and offers a wider spread of CBD:THC ratios (10:1 and 2:1) than most competitors, which typically ship one fixed ratio.
Most hemp-derived THC mints on the market contain between 0.5mg and 3mg of Delta-9 THC per mint, designed for microdosing rather than a strong psychoactive effect.
Hemp-derived Delta-9 THC mints are federally legal under the 2018 Farm Bill when they contain less than 0.3% Delta-9 THC by dry weight. State laws vary, so confirm legality where you live before purchasing.
Beginners generally do better with a higher CBD-to-THC ratio, such as 10:1, which buffers the psychoactive effect. More experienced users often prefer a 2:1 or 1:1 ratio for a stronger, faster effect.